I had major high hopes for this pattern. The versions on Pattern Review are so cute and I LOVE Amanda's version. Alas, it was not to be for me and that's okay. Let's get on with the details of what went wrong.
Problem 1: adding seam allowances to armhole princess seams
I made the first muslin way back in 2021 and had a terrible time adding seam allowances to the armhole princess seams. I could not figure out how to properly sew what resulted in a comically long pointy end. I didn't know how far up (??) I was supposed to extend the seam allowances and it resulted in some weirdness when it came time to sew and press the seam to one side.
Eventually I figured that I can sew to the dot and leave the pointy end loose. Then just tack it down in the seam allowance of the armhole.
muslin from 2026
I started a topic on Threadloop seeking advice because I just knew there had to be another way. One member shared video and a website that explains exactly how to do it, so I am confident that I can properly add seam allowances...on a different jacket pattern. This one is done done.
Problem 2: converting armhole princess seams to shoulder princess seams
In the middle of sourcing how to add the seam allowances, I decided to try and convert the armhole princess seams to shoulder princess seams. Members on Pattern Review shared some good tips and a link to an older blog post that showed how to do this. The problem with this pattern is that the side front panel is unusually narrow - at least more narrow than what I am used to.
If I were to follow the armhole princess line using this piece, the seam would fall on my side bust and that just doesn't look right at all.
So I created my own shoulder princess line on the center front panel which left the invisible waist dart unresolved. Since I love chocolate, I figured I would probably need the extra width and just left it alone.
I know I did not draw a proper waist curve (near the two pattern weights). In the end, it didn't really matter because the fit was off for other reasons.
The other issue with converting to shoulder princess seams is the seam joining the back to the front is actually about two inches toward the back - and NOT at the shoulder. Not a problem, in theory. But in practice, I ended up with a weird curve in the pattern that doesn't look right or lay properly.
At first, I cut this piece off and added seam allowances at the shoulder line. But when sewing the muslin, all the extra seams in this area felt like too much.
You can kind of see the curve near the top of the photo. Armhole princess seams would definitely be better with these design lines.
Problem 3: the jacket is REALLY short
I am five feet tall. Even after adding two inches in length, the un-hemmed jacket barely clears my bust. Dear reader, it is NOT a good look. The proportions are very off and it looks like football padding. It's weird. Very weird. I don't have any pictures because I threw the shell away. It was too much to keep looking at it and I needed immediate separation. 😅
Problem 4: fabric is too lightweight
The fabric I chose was a wool herringbone suiting from Fabric.com (RIP). Even with lining and interfacing, the fabric would've still been too light. This pattern benefits from something much sturdier like denim/twill or wool melton. I still have just under two yards of the fabric, so I'll make a vest or skirt with it.
Conclusion: I will not revisit this pattern again. After two attempts spanning five years, it's safe to say this one isn't for me - unless I do a LOT more adjustments. There are other military-style jacket patterns that I can try for what could be a lot less hassle. Win some, lose some. The pattern pieces have already been recycled. 😎
L






